Herbal Stimulants as Weight Loss Aids: Are They Effective and Safe
By Linda Feingold, M.Ed., M.S., R.D.
Introduction
Desperate times call for desperate measures - or so it seems. In a society where
television and movie stars are shrinking, yet the food supply is increasing, it's no wonder
why people are searching for new ways to mold their bodies into "perfection". As proper
dieting and exercise demand determination and consistency, more and more people are
falling for bogus claims of fast, easy weight loss touted by unscrupulous manufacturers
of herbal diet aids. Although many of these dietary supplements contain "natural"
ingredients, questions exist regarding both the safety and efficacy of these products. This
article discusses some of the more popular, yet controversial, herbal stimulants currently
marketed towards those yearning to lose weight.
Ephedra / Ma Huang
Perhaps the most popular herbal dieting agent on the market today is ephedra,
also known by its Chinese name, ma huang. Ephedra has been used for over 5,000 years
in China to treat respiratory ailments (3,5,7). About 40 species of the plant are known to
be in existence, the most widely used being Ephedra sinica (1,4). The active constituents
of the ephedra plant are known as alkaloids. Ephedrine and pseudoephedrine are the
main alkaloid compounds derived from ma huang and their amounts vary according to
the plant source. These compounds are classified as central nervous system (CNS)
stimulants and can be found in some popular over-the-counter drugs and prescribed
medications. Ephedrine is used in asthma medications and pseudoephedrine is a
component of many nasal decongestants. Ephedrine, while derived from the ma huang
plant, may also be produced synthetically (38).
Ephedra and ephedrine alkaloids are thought to enhance weight loss by both
decreasing appetite and increasing thermogenesis (the body's ability to expend energy)
(22,31,34). Few studies have demonstrated the effectiveness of ephedra alone on weight
loss. When ma huang is "stacked" with other stimulants, such as caffeine, the weight
loss results appear to be more desirable (22, 23, 24, 26, 27, 29, 31). Nevertheless, side
effects may occur from the consumption of ephedra alone. Ma huang may produce the
following adverse effects: increased heart rate, increased blood pressure (diastolic and
systolic), palpitations, insomnia, nervousness, dizziness and headache (1,10,38). The
Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has received over 1,000 complaints of side effects
as well as reports of over 50 deaths attributed to the usage of ephedra-containing
products (39,40,41). It is therefore advised that people with known heart disease or high
blood pressure, diabetes and thyroid disease refrain from taking products containing
ephedra or ephedrine alkaloids (3,7,14). Even cases of acute hepatitis and psychiatric
illness have been attributed to the use of ephedrine products (13,17). Currently, the FDA
recommends no more than 8mg of ephedrine be consumed every six hours with a
maximum intake of 24mg per day (1,41). In August of 2000, a public meeting was held
by the Department of Health and Human Services to discuss the safety of ephedra (42).
The government has since been asked by some of the major ephedra manufacturers to
support further research on ephedra (42).
Related to ephedra is the synthetic drug, Phenylpropanolamine (PPA). It is a
derivative of ephedrine that is said to produce less CNS stimulation than ephedra (10).
PPA can be found in diet aids, such as Dexatrim and in some OTC cough and cold
medications, such as Dimetapp. The usage of PPA has been associated with some
serious side effects, including heart arrhythmias and hemorrhagic strokes (10,43). In
October of 2000, the FDA announced to the public that the dangers of PPA products
warranted immediate discontinuation of their production and is taking steps to ban the
substance entirely. It is likely that the FDA will demand that these products be pulled off
the market soon. Some major drug stores have already voluntarily removed products
containing PPA from their shelves.
Caffeine
Caffeine is the most widely used drug in the world. It is a substance derived from
the following plant sources: coffee, tea, cola/kola, cacao/cocoa, mate and guarana (4).
Most people are aware of the effect caffeine has on the central nervous system, as
millions drink caffeine-containing beverages as a quick "pick me up". Caffeine may also
enhance physical performance, although the mechanisms as to how are not entirely clear.
It has been thought that the ingestion of caffeine may increase lipolysis (the breakdown
of fats) which would appear to be beneficial as the free fatty acids in the bloodstream
would provide energy for activity, thereby delaying the usage of glycogen (carbohydrates
stored in muscle tissue and in the liver) (20,21). However, results from at least two
studies have failed to support this theory (16,19). As a CNS stimulant, caffeine
consumption may decrease the level of perceived exertion, meaning that an individual
may feel less tired during an endurance activity, enabling him or her to continue
exercising for a prolonged period of time (20). Caffeine has not been shown to enhance
the performance of intense, short-acting exercise (37).
There are several side effects associated with the ingestion of caffeine. Caffeine
can increase heart rate, systolic blood pressure and diastolic blood pressure (20).
Restlessness and anxiety are common, as well as sleep fragmentation (20). Acute
withdrawal of caffeine may result in headaches and fatigue (20,33). In addition, caffeine
is a diuretic, and as such, increases the rate and amount of urine output. This can be
detrimental to those who are active, yet already have difficulty drinking the minimum
requirements of 6-8 glasses of water daily. For those who use the dietary supplement,
creatine, caffeine has been shown to counteract creatine's benefits (20).
Combining caffeine with ephedrine has become a popular practice for many
herbal manufacturers. Metabolife 356 is a major seller containing these ingredients. It is
believed that caffeine may enhance the effects of ephedrine (22). Several studies have
shown the combination to be somewhat effective for minor, short-term weight loss, while
the usage of either caffeine or ephedrine alone was not as effective (22-24, 26, 27, 29,
31). The typical dosage in these studies was 20mg ephedrine and 200mg caffeine. Some
of the obese, yet healthy subjects in these studies experienced transient side effects from
the mixture, such as increased blood pressure (22,29), increased or abnormal heart rate
(22,23,29) and nausea (24,27). Aspirin has also been thought to enhance the thermogenic
effect of ephedrine and is typically "stacked" with the caffeine/ephedrine mixture
(28,30,33). Aspirin, itself, is not without side effects. Excessive use of aspirin may
produce gastric bleeding, stomach upset, or prolonged bleeding time (36). White willow
bark is an herb commonly used instead of aspirin in thermogenic aids as it contains
similar properties but may result in less digestive distress when taken (44). Stacker 2,
Stacker 3, and Hydroxycut are examples of products that contain the
ephedra/caffeine/aspirin "stack".
Given the potential dangers of consuming caffeine and ephedrine separately, one
must conclude that the risks are greater when these products are combined. It is therefore
essential that not only the administration of products containing the "stack" be clearly
monitored, but the added everyday use of caffeine-containing beverages, aspirin, OTC
cold medications and asthma medicines must be considered as well.
Ginseng
Asian ginseng, known as Panax ginseng, is an herbal root that has been used as
an energy tonic in the Orient for centuries (45). The active constituents of ginseng are
known as ginsenosides. It takes approximately 6 years for the root to cultivate and for
the ginsenosides to fully develop, thereby making ginseng a valuable and expensive
commodity (4,38). Ginseng can be purchased in several forms: teas, powders, extracts,
tablets, beverages, etc. Although the benefits of ginseng have been studied extensively,
the research is a bit fuzzy when it comes to exercise performance enhancement (7).
Ginseng is believed to enhance physical activity by increasing muscle strength and
aerobic capacity (7,35). It may also improve mental performance by increasing reaction
times (45,7). However, some studies did not show any improvement in exercise
performance (46,47). The usage of stimulants, such as caffeine and ephedra, along with
ginseng is contraindicated (45). A "ginseng abuse syndrome" was noted in the late
1970's describing case reports of sleeplessness, nervousness, hypertension, and diarrhea
(4,7,45). However, these symptoms may have been related to the large doses of caffeine
that the subjects claimed to have taken alongside the ginseng. Nonetheless, people with
high blood pressure and heart ailments should not take ginseng.
Government Regulations Regarding Dietary Supplements
The Dietary Supplement Health Education Act (DSHEA) of 1994 is more
permissive than the laws that govern drugs and medicines. While drug manufacturers
must provide proof of efficacy and safety of their products before they are approved for
the market, the DSHEA placed the burden of proof of safety on the FDA rather than on
the manufacturers of dietary supplements (8). Therefore, rather than proving a dietary
supplement is safe before it goes on the market, the FDA must first prove that it is
harmful before pulling it off the shelves. As the result of lax standards, many products
may become adulterated with substances other than those listed on the labels and/or may
contain more, less, or even none of the ingredients which are listed on the labels. At least
two studies that tested different products containing ephedra noted that the ephedrine
amounts of many of those tested were not equivalent to the amounts listed on their labels
(11,6). Ginseng products have long been under the gun for providing less ginsenosides
than are listed due to the increasing demand for the oftentimes expensive herb (45).
It can be concluded from the research regarding herbal stimulants that the term
"natural" is not necessarily synonymous with "safe". Given the questionable ingredients
of popular dietary supplements, it is wise for consumers to be cautious about taking
them. People should always consult their physicians prior to taking any supplement,
especially if they are currently taking prescribed medications. In addition, none of the
aforementioned products will provide benefits for weight loss without the incorporation
of proper dieting and exercise.
References
- Kleiner SM, Greenwood-Robinson M.
High-Performance Nutrition: The Total Eating Plan to Maximize Your Workout. New York,
New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.;
1996.
- Chan ELP, Ahmed TM, Wang M, Chan JCM.
History of medicine and nephrology in
American Journal of Nephrology. 1994;14:285-301.
- Bucci LR.
Selected herbals and human exercise performance.
American
Journal of Clinical Nutrition.
2000;72(Suppl):624S-636S.
- O’Mathuna DP.
Alternative dieting aids:
effectiveness and safety. Institute for Natural Resources.
2000;9600:1-16.
- Tyler
VE. The
Honest Herbal: A Sensible Guide to the
Use of Herbs and Related Remedies. Third
Edition. Binghamton, New York:
Pharmaceutical Products Press;
1993.
- Astrup A, Breum L, Toubro S, Hein P, Quaade
F. The effect and safety of an
ephedrine/caffeine compound compared to ephedrine, caffeine and placebo in
obese subjects on an energy restricted diet.
A double blind trial. International Journal of Obesity.
1992;16:269-277.
- Astrup A, Toubro S.
Thermogenic, metabolic, and cardiovascular responses to ephedrine
and caffeine in man. International Journal of Obesity.
1993;17(Suppl 1):S41-S43.
- Astrup A, Buemann B, Christensen NJ, Toubro S,
Thorbek G, Victor OJ, Quaade F. The
effect of ephedrine/caffeine mixture on energy expenditure and body composition
in obese women. Metabolism.
1992;41(7):686-688.
- Toubro S, Astrup A, Breum L, Quaade F.
The acute and chronic effects of
ephedrine/caffeine mixtures on energy expenditure and glucose metabolism in
humans. International Journal of Obesity.
1993;17(Suppl 3):S73-S77.
- Bell DG, Jacobs I, McLellan TM, Zamecnik J.
Reducing the dose of combined caffeine and
ephedrine preserves the ergogenic effect.
Aviation, Space, and Environmental Medicine
2000;71(4):415-419.
- Bell DG, Jacobs I.
Combined caffeine and ephedrine ingestion improves run times of
canadian forces warrior test. Aviation, Space, and Environmental Medicine.
1999;70(4):325-329.
- Bell DG, Jacobs I, Zamecnik J.
Effects of caffeine, ephedrine and their
combination on time to exhaustion during high-intensity exercise.
European Journal of Applied Physiology.
1998;77:427-433.
- Toubro S, Astrup A, Breum L, Quaade F.
Safety and efficacy of long-term treatment
with ephedrine, caffeine and an ephedrine/caffeine mixture.
International 1993;17(Suppl 1):S69-S72.
- Fillmore CM, Bartoli L, Bach R, Park, Y.
Nutrition and dietary supplements.
Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation Clinica of North America.
1999;10(3):673-703.
- Dietary
Supplements Containing Ephedrine Alkaloids.
Federal Register.
June 4, 1997; 62:30677.
- Schardt D. Fat burners. Nutrition Action Health Letter.
1999;26(6):9-11.
- Lehrman
S. Natural-born fat killers: Do they offer hope or are they just
hype? Health. 2000;September:70-78.
- White LM, Gardner SF, Gurley BJ, Marx MA, Wang
PL, Estes M. Pharmacokinetics and
cardiovascular effects of ma-huang (Ephedra
sinica) in normotensive adults. Journal of Clinical Pharmacology.
1997;37:116-122.
- Nadir A, Agrawal S, King PD, Marshall JB.
Acute hepatitis associated with the use of a
chinese herbal product, ma-huang. The American Journal of Gastroenterology.
1996;91(7):1436-1437.
- Capwell RR.
Ephedrine-induced mania from an herbal diet supplement.
American 1995;152(4):647.
- Ephedra
Education Council. Dietary supplement
industry calls on FDA to adopt national standards on ephedra.
http:
Accessed October 29,2000.
- Food and
Drug Administration. FDA issues public
health warning on phenylpropanolamine.
http:
Accessed November 8,2000.
- Sinclair CJD, Geiger JD.
Caffeine use in sports: a pharmacological review.
Journal of Sports Medicine and Physical Fitness. 2000;40:71-79.
- Adler GK.
Editorial: exercise and fatigue- is neuroendocrinology an important factor?
The Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism.
2000;85(6):2167-2169.
- Van Baak MA, Saris WHM.
The effect of caffeine on endurance
performance after nonselective beta-adrenergic blockade.
Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise. 2000;32(2):499-503.
- Graham TE, Spriet LL. Metabolic, catecholamine, and exercise performance responses to various doses of caffeine. Journal of Applied Physiology.
1995;78(3):867-874.
- Robergs RA, Roberts SO. Exercise Physiology: Exercise,
Performance, and Clinical Applications.
New York, New York: 1997.
- Battig K.
Acute and chronic cardiovascular and behavioural effects of caffeine,
aspirin and ephedrine. International Journal of Obesity.
1993;17(Suppl 1):S61-S64.
- Daly PA, Krieger DR, Dulloo AG, Young JB,
Landsberg L. Ephedrine, caffeine and
aspirin: safety and efficacy for treatment of human obesity. International Journal of Obesity. 1993;17(Suppl 1):S73-S78.
- Dulloo AG.
Ephedrine, xanthines and prostaglandin-inhibitors:
actions and interactions in the stimulation
of thermogenesis. International Journal of Obesity.
1993;17(Suppl 1):S35-S40.
- 31. Nursing97 Books.
Nursing97 Drug Handbook. Springhouse,
Pennsylvania: Springhouse Corporation; 1997.
- Phillips B. Sports Supplement Review: Third Issue.
Golden, Colorado: Mile High Publishing; 1997.
- Bergner P. The
Healing Power of Ginseng & The Tonic Herbs: The Enlightened Person’s Guide. Prima Publishing: 1996.
- Pieralisi G, Ripari P, Vecchiet L.
Effects of a standardized ginseng extract
combined with dimethylaminoethanol bitartrate, vitamins, minerals, and trace
elements on physical performance during exercise.
Clinical therapeutics. 1991;13(3):373-382.
- Engels HJ, Wirth JC. No ergogenic effects of
ginseng (Panax ginseng C. A. Meyer) during graded maximal aerobic
exercise. Journal of the American Dietetic Association.
1997;10:1110-1115.
- Allen JD, McLung J, Nelson AG, Welsch M.
Ginseng supplementation does not enhance young adults’ peak aerobic
exercise performance. Journal of the American College of Nutrition
1998;17(5):462-466.
- Burdock GA. Dietary supplements and lessons to be learned from GRAS.
Regulatory 2000;31:68-76.
- Gurley BJ, Wang P, Gardner SF.
Ephedrine-type alkaloid content of nutritional supplements containing
Ephedra sinica (ma-huang) as determined by high performance liquid
chromatography. Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences.
1998;87(12):1547-1553.
- Hasegawa GR.
Uncertain quality of dietary supplements: history repeated.
American Journal of Health-System
2000;57:951.
|